Abstract

CORTASSA, Carina G.. Del déficit al diálogo, ¿y después?: Una reconstrucción crítica de los estudios de comprensión pública de la ciencia. Rev. iberoam. cienc. tecnol. soc. [online]. 2010, vol.5, n.15, pp.47-72. ISSN 1850-0013.

This paper presents a critical analysis of the current research programmes in the field of Public Understanding of Science: the well-known public deficit model, and the ethnographic-contextual approach. I begin by examining their respective contributions to the definition of the main interests and questions that shapes the scene, and I will challenge the widespread view that considers that the original frame has been superseded once and for all. Contrary to this belief, I will argue that its persistence as a major focus of conceptual debates has led the discipline to a standstill, consequence of carrying on ascribing cognitive deficit the status of an unsolved problem. Against this, I will propone an alternative approach that assumes the epistemic asymmetry between experts, publics and interface agents as an objective initial condition of the interactions through which scientific knowledge can be socially shared. The paper closes suggesting a set of original questions that arises from this shift, which may contribute to the development of a new agenda for future research. 

Keywords : Deficit model; Etnographic-contextual approac; Epistemic interaction; Asymmetric agents.

        · abstract in Spanish     · text in Spanish     · Spanish ( pdf )