Nowhere is the question of cultural diversity more relevant than in Canada, a country forged by Native peoples,1 Inuit, Metis, European settlers and waves of immigrants from all over the world. When it comes to considering how this mosaic2 features in children and young adults books and the publishing world, Canadian book publishers for children and teenagers acknowledge that even if there is still work to be done to produce books that reflect current racial and cultural realities, their long history of working toward diversity is not to be downplayed. Many of today’s publishing houses started with a mandate to reflect the multicultural and multi-ethnic makeup of a modern progressive Canada and among the many Canadian children and young adult’s presses which haven taken strides in publishing diverse authors are houses such as Annick Press, Fifth House, Second Story, Theytus Books, Viking, or Inhabit Media.
The beginning of an indigenous literature in Canada came about in the nineteenth century in the form of catechism and alphabets published in Montreal, Quebec City or Halifax, locations of the first printing presses in Canada (Watson, 2001, p. 587); yet, the first works for children by Canadian writers were commonly published in New York, Boston or London. Furthermore, these publications written from the metropolitan centres aimed at middle-class domestic readers and displayed a fascination with the exotic and unfamiliar. As Gail Edwards holds in Picturing Canada: A History of Canadian Children’s Illustrated Books and Publishing:
For young readers, the idea of `Canada´ was shaped by narratives that emphasized geographic and cultural otherness- a place of ice and snow, dark and dangerous wooded forests, infinite prairie expanses, and towering mountains, populated by mysterious, savage, and primitive peoples and dangerous animals (Edwards, 2010, p. 17).
Even if in 1912 under the guidance of Lillian Smith the Toronto Public Library saw the establishment of a highly acclaimed library service for children, between 1921 and 1950 the average range of children’s titles published annually was of about ten (Watson, 2001, p. 587). The domestic market for Canadian authors and publishers was thus weak and this, together with the extent of sales of foreign titles, were worrying facts in the rising Canadian nationalism of the late 1960s and early 70s and the unrelentingly growing awareness of a multicultural society.
The fact that multiculturalism is formally acknowledged and incorporated in Canada’s3 constitution reveals its significance for the nation’s psyche. As Eva Mackey observes, its import to the creation of national identity and to the success of the nation- building project can be traced back to the 1960s when management and representation of that diversity revealed to be central to the realization of that project. The 1967 centennial celebrations were a high point in Canadian state-produced national sentiment. Among other things, a bicultural vision of the nation started to emerge and native people and “ethnic groups”4 acquired visibility in the celebrations (Mackey, 2002, p. 58). The 1970s, in turn, saw a growth and institutionalization of this project when the state attempted a clearer definition of the boundaries and hierarchies of difference in the Canadian nation.
From a historical perspective then the changes in the perception and status of ethnicity in Canada were slow until 1971. In that year multiculturalism became the official policy and there were substantial proclamations of responsibility concerning ethnic diversity. When Canada was recognized as multicultural by Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau, `Multiculturalism within a Bilingual Framework´ became not just the official state policy but also the sum and substance of Canadian identity. Following the 1969 Official Languages Act, which officially declared the country bilingual, the Canada’s Multiculturalism Policy secured that two official languages coexisted but no official culture and no ethnic group would prevail. In this sense Canadian multiculturalism is decidedly entrenched in Canadian biculturalism. Yet, as Genetsch claims, the Ottawa-Quebec biculturalism, or Hugh Mac Lennan’s `two solitudes´ which has marked the image Canada projected of itself, is but a myth and a simplification. Firstly, Canada’s colonial history and the appropriation of land based on the concept of terra nullius, or an `empty space´, worked towards leaving out the Inuit and Native Indians, denying them the status of founding nations and disempowering them. Secondly, because of Canada’s promotion of immigration, a large number of the population was neither of English or French descent nor belonged to the First Nations communities (Genetsch, 2007, pp. 1-2).
As a symbolic intervention, the policy of multiculturalism was then, according to Eva Mackey, an attempt to manage a potentially dangerous political situation through the recognition and management of culture. Multicultural policy extends the state recognition of multiple forms of difference so as to undercut Quebec’s more threatening difference (Mackey, 2002, p. 64). Thus, the inauguration of multiculturalism was firstly aimed at defusing Quebec’s claims of secession and secondly represented an attempt to redefine the symbolic system of Canada. Even if the implementation of the policy of multiculturalism aimed at sapping the strength of the secessionist claims of Quebec, the fact that a policy of assimilation was abandoned in favor of normative pluralism contributed to forging a national identity conceived as a mosaic, a Canadian national identity which inheres in the very difference of the nation’s diverse cultures.
During periods of nationalist effervescence, namely after the introduction of Canadian citizenship, in the wake of the Canadian centennial, and upon the repatriation of the Canadian Constitution, there was a major development in publishing. According to Richter, the new availability of both national and provincial funding which explicitly supported publishing for children also exemplifies the strong political involvement in the creation of Canadian children’s literature. Awards on the national, provincial and regional level have worked towards fostering Canadian publishing for children and, the creation of a national canon of Canadian children’s literature (Richter, 2011, p. 294).
Many years after all these and other significant political, social and cultural developments started to take place in Canada, more specifically on November 9, 2013, some 250 guests gathered at the Toronto Public Library’s Lillian H. Smith branch to celebrate the 35th anniversary of Groundwood Books, one of Canada’s oldest children’s book publishers. Groundwood founder Patsy Aldana5 was absent from the party since she was in China inaugurating an imprint for China Children’s Press and Publications Group, the country’s largest children’s book publisher. In 1978, Aldana, at the time president of the Association of Canadian Publishers, borrowed $30,000 from her mother and started Groundwood Books. She was then 32 years old. In 1979 Aldana became manager for Douglas & McIntyre,6 the Vancouver-based publishing company which initially distributed Groundwood’s books and then merged “in a complex relationship unique in Canadian publishing”, which was crucial for the growth and expansion of the company (Edwards, 2010, p. 103). Douglas & McIntyre, on the lookout for a Toronto outpost, purchased Groundwood’s inventory while Aldana continued keeping control over the company and all copyrights.
According to Aldana, the reason that drove her to found Groundwood was an awareness of a paucity of Canadian children’s titles. Books such as Anne of Green Gables (1908) by Lucy Maud Montgomery, Alligator Pie (1974) by Dennis Lee and other similar titles had been successful in the market, but except for Tundra Books there were no publishers specializing in children’s literature. “Because I worked at a children’s bookstore and I was working at the Women’s Press,” she said, “I could see that there was a real hunger and need for Canadian children’s books” (Williams, 2013). She had to put up a fight against the deeply entrenched notion that Canadian children’s books were not valuable and, least of all, marketable. “I remember a conference in Vancouver, and all these people were going around saying Canadian books are terrible,” she recounted. “That was before Groundwood actually started, and I remember thinking, ‘Well, we’ll show them.’ According to her, that if a publisher puts out high-quality Canadian children’s books, there would be a market, and she was right (Williams, 2013).
The early 1980s happened to be an exceptional time to publish Canadian children’s books. Not only could children’s bookstores be found in most major Canadian cities, but also, according to Aldana, it was ‘the great heyday of Canadian school libraries. Every school felt they had to have a library, and the librarians were properly trained and they were interested in Canadian authors” (Williams, 2013).
When nearing the end of the decade questions related to authenticity of voice rose to prominence, Aldana said she realized there was a lack of diversity in Canadian children’s literature. Unlike the U.S. publishing houses which were bringing out good quality books written by black authors featuring black children, in Canada there was scant writing by any minority authors. “That’s where we found a niche that was different from other people, and it became a specialty for Groundwood,” she remarked wile she cited Paul Yee’s Tales from Gold Mountain, about the exploitation of Chinese immigrants, and Thomas King’s controversial A Coyote Columbus Story, a folkloric take on 1492 told from the native North American perspective, as titles that helped build Groundwood’s reputation (Williams, 2013).
In 2005 Aldana arranged for Scott Griffin, who had recently purchased House of Anansi Press, to acquire Groundwood Books from Douglas & McIntyre (Medley, 2012) and in January 2013 Aldana officially stepped down from her role as publisher and Sheila Barry took over. When Barry died on November 15, 2017. Semareh Al-Hillal7 was named publisher of Groundwood in April.
Groundwood Books, which accounts for 40% to 50% of Anansi’s revenue in any given year, is primarily an institutional publisher rather than a trade publisher. This means they predominantly sell to schools and libraries rather than through stores. (Medley 2012) Groundwood thus, even if not the first dedicated to children,8 has undoubtedly pioneered Canadian topics and multicultural themes such as the ones present in the books under consideration, namely Tales from Gold Mountain. Stories of the Chinese in the New World (1989), A Coyote Columbus Story (1992) and My name is Seepeetza (1992).
Paul Yee’s Tales from Gold Mountain: Stories of the Chinese in the New World was first published in 1989 and was last reprinted in paper format in 2011 and in digital format in 2014. This picture-book illustrated by Simon Ng and edited by Michael Solomon was winner of the Sheila A. Egoff Children’s Literature Prize, the IODE Violet Downey Book Award and the IODE National Chapter Award. The book contains a landmark collection of eight stories which describe the extraordinary circumstances of the Chinese who came to build the railroad in Canada and the United States. The stylised full-page illustrations by Simon Ng both highlight the poignancy of the narratives and reveals the character nuances of the protagonists. In this book historian and archivist Yee artfully blends historical fact and folklore motifs and conveys the sorrows and hopes of Chinese immigrants coming to Canada in the 19th century to search for gold, build the transcontinental railway, and engage in all kinds of menial jobs.
Yee, who considers himself to be third-generation Canadian, though actually he is the first one in his family to be born in Canada, thus writes from an inside perspective about what it means to be a member of a visible community in Canada. These stories, by offering Chinese-Canadians knowledge about their history, reveal an awareness of the importance of shared history and culture for identity formation. The popular historical phrase Gumshan or “Gold Mountain”, a key signifier in the Chinese North American imagination, is strategically used in the title and is also structured in the framework of the book. The opening story, “Spirits of the Railway”, and the closing one, “The Revenge of the Iron Chink”, feature the historical presence of the Chinese immigrants in pioneer projects of the Canadian Pacific Railway and the British Columbia salmon industry. Both stories contextualise the physical hardships which the traditional legendary heroes in myth have to face, one in the building of the railway and the other in the frontier industry which exploited salmon. As to the social milieu, both stories depict the racial discrimination and dehumanizing social environment the labourers have to face. In “The Friends of Kwan Ming” portrays the fates of Chinese immigrants in a job market which offered them positions ony in the service industry whereas in “Gambler’s Eyes” Yee engages with the prejudice and discrimination which a man of mixed descent has to live through both in Chinatown and among the Caucasian population. In “Ginger for the Heart”, “Sons and Daughters” and “Forbidden fruit” Yee takes issue with the subordination of women in a male-oriented social order and in “Rider Chan and the Night River” the author fleshes out a minority hero who, working as a courier on the frontiers in the days of the Gold Rush, keeps watch over the moral order of Gold Mountain.
These folktales have a three-fold nature, creating mythology as a foundation, securing Chinese-Canadians recognition9 by other cultural groups in Canada and affording them a better understanding of Canada’s largest racial minority (Richter, 2011, p. 276). Yee’s stories are thus part of a collective voice8 which not only brings out a an experience and a heritage largely unrecorded, excluded or misrepresented by the media but also serves to redress this historical injustice, to deal with issues of Chinese Canadian history and to confront racism past and present (Chao, 1997, p. X). Furthermore, Yee’s craftmanship as a storyteller together with the power of Ng’s illustrations attest to the power of legend and myth to reach out to an audience which includes more than children and encompasses “anybody who wanted to read stories” (Yee, 1990, p. 346).
A Coyote Columbus Story by Thomas King,10 first released by Groundwood in 1992. was inspired by the quincentennial of the Columbus’ voyage in 1492. King had tried for many years to find a publisher for his book in the USA and eventually he found one in Canada, in Groundwood Books, by then an imprint of Douglas & McIntyre. The book which is aimed at 5-8 old readers, was short-listed for the Governor General’s Literary Awards in 1992, and has gone through many printings, the last being in 2007.
Thomas King, author of Cherokee-Greek descent, has written both adult and children’s books11 addressing the Aboriginal question. Unlike adult fiction, picture books for children do not show the same unblinking view of oppression, abuse, poverty, poor health; rather, as Wolf and DePasquale hold, the one striking difference between them lies in tone (Wolf & DePasquale, 2008, p. 91) and locating these darkness and anger topoi becomes a problem of reading and not of content. They are undoubtedly there, though crucially meshed with “a sense of cultural affirmation, renewal and hope” which cannot be untangled from pressures, on the one hand, to produce images which counteract stereotypical views of “the drunken, lazy, or promiscuous Indian” and, on the other, to meet the general expectations of age appropriateness related to children’s literature (Wolf & DePasquale, 2008, p. 91).
In A Coyote Columbus Story, Thomas King chose to tell a new kind of Columbus story, a retelling from a Native point of view in which Coyote,12 the trickster, creates the world and all the creatures in it. She is in full control of events until a funny-looking red-haired man named Columbus disrupts her plans. Unimpressed by the wealth of moose, turtles and beavers in Coyote’s land, columbus instead is interested in the human beings he can take to sell in Spain.
Thomas King deploys a good number of literary devices and tricks to challenge the stereotypes surrounding the Voyages of Discovery. In doing so, he naughtily beckons children to laugh with him at the crazed pranks of Coyote, who inadvertently and haphazardly allows Columbus to cause the ruin of his human friends. More importantly, in his creation, King makes the point that history is not neutral and is, undoubtedly, influenced by the culture of the reporter. The originality of the book lies not only in the pungent storyline but also in William Kent Monkman’s psychodelic illustrations that bring everything fully to life. My Name is Seepeetza, by Salish writer Shirley Sterling,13 was published by Groundwood on November 1st, 1992 and since that time the book has gone into its thirteenth reprint, the last being in 2008. The book, aimed at students in grades 4 - 7 but often read by adults, has been acclaimed in both Canada and the United States. In Canada it was short-listed for a Governor General’s Award in 1993 and won the Sheila A. Egoff Children’s Literature Prize and the Laura Steiman Award for Children’s Literature.
The reading frame for My Name is Seepeetza is the sad fate of approximately 150,000 First Nations, Métis, and Inuit children who were, for over a century, removed from their homes and sent to live in residential schools14 across Canada. The schools were created and funded by the federal government in the belief that Indigenous peoples were uncivilized and needed to be ‘saved’ from themselves. In reality, that ‘education’ cost Indigenous children the loss of their families and communities, their indigenous languages, and their traditions.
Sterling, in the voice of a 10-year-old girl who keeps a secret journal in a fictional place called Kalamak, in British Columbia, recounts her experiences in the Kamloops Indian Residential School15 in the late 1950s. At a time when First Nations children were forcibly taken from their parents under threat of prison, forbidden to speak their language and often suffered all forms of abuse and neglect, Seepeetza offers readers an insight into the loneliness she experiences with a frank and candid approach for young readers. Herdaily entries, from September 1958 to August 1959, relate the mundane and the horrific, from coping with schoolyard bullies to the death of a young boy by hanging. What shines through is the indomitable spirit of childhood.
Now on reading lists from Grade 4 classrooms to universities throughout North America, My Name is Seepeetza has been hailed for its power to bring memory forward and to acknowledge a trauma which is part of Canadian history.
According to Royson James (Grimaldi, 2014), the purpose of encouraging children to read is not simply to promote literacy. Literature has powerful qualities beyond didactic practicality. The aim is to introduce literature that a child can invest in-that will provide both intellectual stimulation and emotional reinforcement. Books that raise questions of culture, familial identity, and social surroundings are crucial to this process. To ignite a love of literature, one must encourage literature with which students can identify: one that speaks to their fears, their interests, their needs.
Groundwood Books’ mission as spelt out on its website is “to publish books dedicated to the production of children’s books of the highest possible quality for all ages, including fiction, picture books and nonfiction.” Their primary focus is “on works by Canadians” although they “sometimes also publish outstanding books from other countries”. These books “tell the stories of people whose voices are not always heard. Books by the First Peoples of this hemisphere have always been a special interest, as have those of others who through circumstance have been marginalized and whose contribution to our society is not always visible” (House of Anasi).
The books surveyed in this article, namely Paul Yee’s Tales from Gold Mountain, Thomas King’s A Coyote Columbus Story and Shirley Sterling’s My Name is Seepeetza intervene thus in the sphere of “institutionalized multiculturalism”, activating other elements which, on the one hand, inscribe ethnicity as a differential sign and which, on the other, do not bracket off the history of the ethnic subject. Authors and illustrators from non-dominant ethno-cultural groups work towards giving voice to the subaltern and articulating the tensions of marginalized and minority groups by speaking from the in-between of institutionalised multiculturalism.
In coming to address issues concerning Native peoples and the constitution of a hyphenated identity within the ongoing process of Canada’s nation-building, Groundwood Books’ publishing practice situates ethnic difference and the diasporic condition within a field of both contestation and hope arising from the interaction of Old and New Canadians; more importantly, Groundwood crafts and enacts a new and much needed poetics in children’s books.