INTRODUCTION
Focal and segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS) accounts for nearly 40% of all cases of nephrotic syndrome (NS) in adults, and along with other glomerular diseases, is responsible for the second, after diabetic nephropathy, most frequent cause of end stage renal disease (ESRD).1 Its pathogenesis is highlighted by damage to glomerular podocytes, by unidentified factor, leading to foot process’ effacement, denudation of basement membrane with subsequent hyalinization and glomerular sclerosis, causing progressive loss of renal function.2The main histopathological feature of the disease is hyalinization of glomerular tufts, expansion of mesangial matrix and mononuclear cell infiltrate in the tubulointerstitium. Variable expression of these lesions in individual cases formed basis for identification of five histologic variants of the FSGS.3These types present as distinct clinical entities, with different course and response to treatment, including glomerular tip lesion, collapsing glomerulopathy, peri-hilar and cellular types, along with poorly defined “not otherwise specified” (NOS) FSGS glomerulopathy. The latter is regarded as the most common variant, occurring in approximately 62% of cases.4The main clinical manifestations of FSGS comprise proteinuria (including NS and its consequences), arterial hypertension and progressive loss of glomerular filtration. The principal purpose of treatment is remission of proteinuria, good hypertension control and halting progression of renal failure. The overall prognosis is unfavorable, since approximately 50% of patients reach ESRD at 10 years after diagnosis.2
Goal of the study
The main purpose of the study was to identify determinants of the short-term outcome of primary FSGS within the first year of diagnosis. In this regard we have tried to find out, whether the severity of disease at presentation influenced the patients' outcome 12 months later.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
A retrospective analysis was performed on clinical data of patients, hospitalized in department of nephrology, in the years 2008-2016, due to NF, with biopsy proven FSGS, as part of standard diagnostic procedure. The histological assessment of percutaneous renal biopsy specimens was based on evaluation of light and immunofluorescence microscopic images. A possibility of secondary FSGS was ruled out on clinical and anamnestic grounds, by excluding subjects with evident exposure to toxins, infections and conditions characterized by glomerular hyperfiltration.5
In each patient renal function was assessed by serum creatinine concentration (sCr) and equilibrated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) value, the latter using abbreviated MDRD equation. Moreover, serum total protein and albumin concentrations were taken into account. Proteinuria was expressed as protein to urinary creatinine ratio (UPCR), assessed in the morning voiding sample. The subsequent evaluation of the above parameters was performed every 3 months after diagnosis.
The complete remission criteria were the following: a fall of the UPCR below 0.3, along with sCR within limits of normal and serum albumins above 3.5 g/dl. UPCR in the range of 0.3-3.5 with stable sCR (change in sCR of up to 25% of the initial value) was regarded as the partial remission criteria. Alternatively, UPCR of 0.3-3.5, provided that it resulted from reduction of proteinuria by at least 50% was also regarded as a partial remission.
Results obtained were presented as means and standard deviations. Statistical analysis was performed using statistical package Statistica (StatSoft, Tulsa, OK, USA). Numerical data were presented as mean values and standard deviations. All these data were evaluated as to the normal distribution, utilizing Shapiro-Wilk W test. Data characterized by normal distribution and meeting the assumption of homogeneity of variances were assessed with t-student test when comparing 2 groups or with the analysis of variances (ANOVA) when comparing at least 3 groups. When with the ANOVA test a zero hypothesis on equality of the groups was discarded, further analysis was performed using post-hoc Bonferroni test. Data lacking normal distribution were assessed utilizing U Mann Whitney test, when comparing 2 groups and nonparametric Chi-square Pearson test for qualitative parameters. Level of statistical significance was set at p 0.05.
RESULTS
84 patients (32 females and 52 males) were enrolled in the study, with histopathologically confirmed primary FSGS NOS histopathological type (Columbia University classification). Main laboratory data of persons enrolled have been presented in the Table 1.
Management of glomerulopathy included supportive antihypertensive therapy with angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitor (ACEI) or angiotensin I receptor blocker (ARB) in 77 subjects (92% of the population enrolled) at a maximal tolerated dose, unless contraindicated. Subsequently, remission induction was undertaken with administration of oral prednisone, starting from 1 mg/kg body weight (up to 60 mg/day) in 65 patients (77% of the total group enrolled). This dosage was continued for 12 weeks, later on tapered to 0.5 mg/kg and carried on for further 12 weeks. In case of non-response to prednisone the therapy was supplemented by calcineurin inhibitors: cyclosporine in 31 persons (37%) or tacrolimus in 3 individuals (6.3%). Intolerance to calcineurin inhibitor resulted in treatment with use of mycophenolate mofetil in 7 patients (8.3%).
As a result of treatment, complete remission of proteinuria, defined by the KDIGO Guidelines6 was attained in 30 subjects (35.7%), partial remission in 37 persons (44%), whereas in 17 patients protein excretion rate remained unchanged (20.2%). Table 2 summarizes patients’ data at completion of observation in the treated group.
Statistical analysis revealed no significant differences in patients enrolled regarding reduction of proteinuria adjusted for patient's age, SCr, and eGFR between enrollment and termination of the study. The pace of achieving remission at the onset of treatment was not demonstrated to influence patient’s outcome following one years’ treatment/observation.
The severity of glomerular injury at initial presentation of the disease appeared to influence it’s early (12 months) outcome: patients attaining early complete remission have had the lowest initial UPCR (1.6), significantly lower than in the partial remitters (UPCR=3.3), as well as in those who have failed to achieve any remission at all (UPCR=5.05). Respective data have been presented in Figure 1 and Table 3.
Statistical analysis has demonstrated that serum albumin concentration at diagnosis could be regarded as a predictor of early remission in response to treatment. It has been documented, employing Bonferroni’s method, that in persons attaining complete remission of proteinuria, albuminemia at the onset of disease (3.7 g/dl) was significantly higher, than in those with partial remission (3.5 g/dl), as well as in patients with no remission (2.7 g/dl). Figure 2 and Table 4 illustrate this finding.
Similarly,the serum albumin concentration at the onset of observation, also serum total
protein concentration was observed to display statistically significant differences. Patients with complete and partial remission of proteinuria have had significantly higher total serum protein concentrations (respectively, complete remission 6.1 g/dl, partial remission 5.8 g/dl) than those in whom remission was not achieved (4.9 g/dl). These results have been illustrated in Figure 3 and Table 5.
As far as the influence of pharmacotherapy on achieving remission is concerned, correlation between remission and medication employed was noted exclusively regarding prednisone. Among patients treated with this drug (N=65), 24 (37%) reached complete remission also 24 (37%) - partial remission, whereas 17 patients (26%) have failed to achieve any remission of proteinuria (P=0.01501). Comparable regularities were not observed for cyclosporine, tacrolimus or mycophenolate mofetil.
DISCUSSION
Early complete remission of NS confers a very good prognosis for the long-term clinical course of primary FSGS.2Histological variants of the disease include cellular, collapsing and NOS, the last one being most frequent, usually seen in over 40% of biopsies of the FSGS cases.7Indeed, all the patients presented in this report were classified as the NOS subtype of primary FSGS. Nevertheless, with the exception of the collapsing type, histological variant hasn’t been demonstrated to significantly impact upon the severity of the disease, or it’s prognosis.8As demonstrated by investigators from the Toronto Glomerulonephritis Registry, also partial response to treatment could be regarded as a significant prognostic factor, heralding beneficial outcome of primary FSGS.9
This positive influence of partial remission on the rate of kidney function decline was seen regardless of the type of histopathological changes and mode of treatment of glomerular injury. In our study, comparable results were obtained concerning fraction of patients reaching remission, although the observation time was to short to draw reliable prognostic conclusions.
Our analysis has demonstrated that the severity of glomerular injury at initial presentation of FSGS impacted upon its clinical course and response to treatment. Conceivably, those patients who have had lower proteinuria and higher serum albumins concentration were more likely to attain complete remission of glomerular injury in response to immunomodulatory treatment with glucocorticoids and/or calcineurin inhibitors. These therapeutic agents are still regarded as a mainstay of drugs inducing remission of FSGS.10
Our results have also pointed at prednisone as the most effective drug in management of glomerular injury caused by primary FSGS, contrary to other immunomodulatory agents used in our study.
Unfortunately, we have not been able to define any early predictors of clinical course in patients with primary FSGS. Nonetheless, it appears from our results that the patients more severely affected by glomerular injury at presentation of the disease are less likely to respond to treatment. Both degree of proteinuria and hypoalbuminemia/hypoproteinemia predicted response to induction of remission. Hypoalbuminemia has been recently identified, by Chinese researchers, as a negative prognostic factor for renal outcome in diabetic nephropathy.11
The weakness of our study is undoubtedly short time of the follow-up, although we have aimed at identifying characteristics and predictive factors of early clinical course in primary FSGS. At this point, it is worth to note that this disease is not a single entity of uniform prognosis, but rather should be regarded as a specific type of clinicopathological presentation of glomerular injury. With this respect, Dutch investigators have identified a subgroup of patients with primary FSGS, of short duration and normal GFR, who regardless of degree of nephrotic presentation were not subjected to immunomodulatory treatment.12
These patients were characterized by high spontaneous remission rate and favorable long-term prognosis: 65% of them were free of proteinuria after 9.4 years follow-up. The authors concluded that in early course FSGS of subjects with normal renal function, the wait-and-see strategy may spare the patients of unnecessary and potentially harmful immunosuppression.
This observation further adds to the complexity of management of FSGS and underlines the necessity of careful and frequent observation of our patients.
Conflict of interest: Authors declare no conflict of interest.