Abstract

MARTINEZ MANRIQUE, Fernando  and  VICENTE, Agustín. Hablar para pensar: sobre el uso del lenguaje en el pensamiento. Anal. filos. [online]. 2008, vol.28, n.1, pp.91-112. ISSN 1851-9636.

This paper examines Carruthers's latest proposal on the role of language as a global broadcaster of thoughts in a massively modular architecture. We focus on two aspects: inner speech as an intermodular integrator, and its function to explain creativity in human cognition. First, we argue that language is not sufficient for intermodular integration from what we call "the audience problem": sentences composed by the linguistic module, combining information from different domains, would be unintelligible to each central module, which is domain-specific. As an alternative, we consider the possibility that there is integration not carried out by a specific module. Finally, we claim that Carruthers's proposal for creative thinking respects neither the phenomenology nor the ambiguity of language. We contend that a mindreading system, which has a crucial function in linguistic communication, must have a much more important role to play.

Keywords : Creativity; Integration; Language; Mindreading; Modularity.

        · abstract in Spanish     · text in Spanish     · Spanish ( pdf )